The Olive Press

Eh.

I don't get where all these reviews are coming from. Excellent? Really? This place is just average. It's no different from any big name chain restaurant like East Side Mario's or Alice Fazooli's. I've only gone once and don't plan on going back unless I'm absolutely desperate for somewhere to dine out.. When we first walked in we were greeted by some gentleman that seemed to be a manager, who asked us how many were in our party. When I opened my mouth to say 3, he turned his back to me and went to answer a phone call, which he stayed on for about 2-3 minutes. During this time several other employees came and went without saying anything. He then finished his phone call and turned back to us and rudely said "what?". We were taken to our table, and had a wonderful young man that served us. Everyone at the table ordered something different, and none of us were pleased with our meals. I got the mushroom ravioli and all I could taste was garlic. The mushrooms were almost raw and still had that awful foamy texture. I also had a peach bellini and was disappointed by the size of it, which was incredibly small. My dad had the Lasagna and again said his was overly garlicy. My mom had Chicken Alfredo and surprise, all she could taste was garlic. After all of our mediocre meals, the bill was still nearly $80. All in all, I don't get the appeal of this place. There's much better Italian food in Downtown Oakville, I guess people just aren't willing to drive the extra 10 minutes for it.

Pasta Takeout was Fine

Having survived takeout pizza a few weeks back, we decided to try ordering from the Olive Press again - this time pasta and a quattro formagio pizza. The pastas (lasagna & sausage penne) were well portioned. We could have shared one between the two of us. The caesar salad was fresh and dressing was fantastic. The garlic bread was boring, but it was garlic bread. The pizza was fantastic according to the teenager in the party, the Mom felt it was dry and bland. The Order was 10 minutes late beyond promised pickup time - not a big deal, but still it was late. We'll order again, more for convenience than cuisine - this is not innovative, it's comfort food.

Fantastic! Service was impeccable, food was hot, fresh and delicious. Interior decor makes it look fancier than it is, but it's really quite casual. Will definitely be returning! My wife is a bit of a picky eater (hi honey!) and the staff and manager bent over backwards to find her something she could eat. Great wine prices too....

This place is fantastic

I honestly don't understand how anyone can have something negative to say about this place. My family and I live around the corner from The Olive Press and frequent about twice a month. The only complaint I can come up with is that on the weekends there is usually a wait. The Honeymoon spaghetti is to die for (though at the upper price point of the menu), as well as the Carbonara - it's a meat lovers dream. Pizzas are also great for pick-up, my kids love the basic Pepp, however the wife always goes for the Parisian Chicken. Only complaint is the restaurant is pretty loud, probably because of the concert floor and open ceiling. - I think

Good meatballs and pasta. Friendly service. Great neighborhood place for a casual meal.